8 Best Tim Hortons Keurig Cups of 2026

Awaken your mornings with a crisp, aromatic lift—Tim Hortons Rocky Mountain Sunrise K-Cups deliver a bright, light roast experience that’s a breath of fresh mountain air in every cup. Crafted from 100% Arabica beans, this blend balances subtle notes of chocolate, fruit, and nuts, creating a smooth, sweet finish that avoids the harshness often found in lighter roasts. It’s the perfect pick for those who crave a clean, morning-friendly coffee without overwhelming bitterness—ideal for early risers and sensitive palates alike.

In real-world testing, the 3.3-ounce pods brew consistently at 8 oz, producing a cup that’s light-bodied yet flavorful, with a delicate acidity that never turns sour. Whether used in a Keurig K-Classic or K-Mini, the extraction is even, preserving the nuanced profile of the beans. While it lacks the bold punch of darker roasts, that’s by design—this is a gentle wake-up call, not a caffeine sledgehammer. However, those seeking a stronger, more robust flavor may find it underwhelming, especially when brewed at larger cup sizes.

Positioned as the best light roast in Tim Hortons’ K-Cup lineup, Rocky Mountain Sunrise stands apart from the brand’s medium and dark offerings by prioritizing clarity and balance over intensity. Compared to the Original Blend, it’s noticeably brighter and more refined, though less full-bodied. It’s a top choice for fans of mild, aromatic coffees who want a single-serve option that doesn’t sacrifice quality. While the 12-count pack offers a short trial, it delivers the same premium Arabica experience as larger bundles—at a noticeably gentler roast profile.

For decaf drinkers who refuse to compromise on taste, Tim Hortons’ Decaf Medium Roast K-Cups are a revelation—delivering the brand’s iconic balanced flavor without the caffeine kick. Each of the 100 pods uses 100% Arabica beans, expertly decaffeinated while preserving the smooth, mellow profile that’s made the Original Blend a staple for over 50 years. This is true decaf done right: rich and satisfying, never flat or watery, making it perfect for evening sipping or caffeine-sensitive mornings.

In daily use, the coffee brews evenly across Keurig models, producing a consistent, medium-bodied cup with mild acidity and a clean finish. The flavor mirrors the classic Original Blend—nutty, slightly sweet, with a toasty warmth—proving that decaf doesn’t mean dull. At 100 count, it’s ideal for households or offices where all-day coffee access is key, and the single-serve format eliminates waste. That said, purists may notice a slight softness in depth compared to its caffeinated sibling, a common trade-off in decaf processing.

When stacked against the regular Original Blend 100ct, this decaf version holds its own as the best low-caffeine option in the Tim Hortons K-Cup range. It’s not as bold as the Dark Roast, nor as vibrant as Rocky Mountain Sunrise, but it fills a crucial niche: reliable, round-the-clock coffee without sleep disruption. For those who want the signature Tim Hortons taste at any hour, this decaf delivers unmatched convenience and flavor integrity. It offers the same aromatic richness as the caffeinated original, just minus the buzz.

Step into a bolder flavor zone with Tim Hortons’ 100% Colombian Medium Dark Roast—a rich, single-origin standout that brings depth and authenticity to the K-Cup format. Sourced entirely from premium Colombian Arabica beans, this red-labeled blend delivers a crisp yet smooth cup with a clean finish and subtle earthy sweetness, offering a more defined terroir than the brand’s signature blends. It’s a roast with character, perfect for those who appreciate a touch of sophistication in their single-serve routine.

Brewed at 8 oz, the coffee shows off its medium-dark profile—toasty, slightly smoky, with a balanced acidity that keeps it from turning bitter. The 12-count pack is ideal for sampling or light use, and each pod extracts cleanly in Keurig machines, leaving no clog or residue. While it lacks the intense punch of the full Dark Roast, it carves its own niche with refined complexity and a smoother edge. However, fans of bolder, more aggressive roasts may find it too restrained, especially when compared to the brand’s full-bodied dark option.

As the best specialty roast in the lineup, this Colombian variant appeals to those seeking a distinctive, origin-driven taste without venturing into third-party brands. It outshines the Original Blend in clarity and bean authenticity, though it doesn’t match the volume of the 100-count packs. For coffee lovers who want a premium, single-origin experience in a convenient pod, it’s a compelling choice. It brings more flavor nuance than the standard blend, even if it sacrifices some strength.

The gold standard of Tim Hortons’ K-Cup collection, the Original Blend 100ct delivers the iconic, balanced coffee experience that’s defined the brand for generations. With a medium roast profile, it strikes a masterful equilibrium—smooth, slightly nutty, with a clean finish and just enough body to feel satisfying without bitterness. These pods use 100% Arabica beans, carefully sourced and roasted to preserve the time-honored recipe known to only three people, making every cup feel like a piece of coffee heritage.

In real-world testing, the 100-count pack proves its worth for daily drinkers—each pod brews consistently across Keurig models, producing a reliable 8 oz cup with no clogging or weak extraction. The flavor remains stable over time, never turning stale or flat, and the single-serve format eliminates waste, making it ideal for homes, offices, or dorms. While not as bold as the Dark Roast or as unique as the Colombian, its strength lies in dependable, crowd-pleasing taste that works at any time of day.

Positioned as the best overall option, this pack outperforms smaller counts and flavored variants by offering maximum value and consistency. Compared to the 24-count Original Blend, it’s more economical per pod and better suited for frequent use. It lacks the novelty of limited editions or the depth of dark roasts, but it excels where it matters most: daily reliability and broad appeal. For those who want a no-fuss, always-right cup, it’s the undisputed champion—delivering the same signature smoothness as the café version, just in pod form.

For lovers of bold, unapologetic coffee, Tim Hortons’ Dark Roast K-Cups deliver a rich, intense brew that punches above its price point. Roasted deeper than the Original Blend, this 100% Arabica coffee boasts a full-bodied profile with smoky depth, low acidity, and a lingering warmth that satisfies black coffee drinkers and cream lovers alike. It’s the darkest option in the Tim Hortons lineup, designed for those who want their morning jolt wrapped in a robust, satisfying flavor.

Brewed at 8 oz, the coffee fills the cup with a deep, aromatic richness that holds up well across Keurig machines—no weak or watery results here. The 100-count pack ensures long-term supply, making it a smart staple for high-volume households or offices. While it doesn’t reach the smoky intensity of some specialty dark roasts, it delivers remarkable consistency and a clean finish without bitterness. However, those who prefer bright, fruity notes or lighter profiles may find it too heavy, especially in larger cup sizes.

As the best dark roast value, this pack competes directly with the Original Blend 100ct but carves its niche with bolder flavor at the same price. It’s not as nuanced as the 100% Colombian, nor as versatile as the medium roast, but it wins on sheer caffeine-powered satisfaction. Ideal for afternoon pick-me-ups or mornings that demand strength, it’s a go-to for dark roast loyalists. It offers more intensity than the Original Blend, without costing more per pod.

For budget-conscious coffee lovers, the 24-count Original Blend K-Cups offer a smart entry point into Tim Hortons’ signature medium roast—delivering the same balanced, smooth flavor as larger packs at a lower upfront cost. With 100% Arabica beans and the brand’s time-tested roast profile, each pod brews a clean, satisfying cup that’s nutty, slightly sweet, and perfectly drinkable black or with cream. It’s the same beloved blend found in cafes, just in a smaller, more flexible format.

In practice, the 24-pack is ideal for light users, travelers, or office break rooms—enough for a few weeks of daily use without bulk commitment. The pods perform flawlessly in Keurig brewers, with no clogging or inconsistent flow, and the single-serve design prevents waste. While it lacks the long-term savings of the 100-count, it’s a cost-effective trial for new users or those testing compatibility. However, frequent drinkers will quickly exhaust the supply, making it less economical over time.

Positioned as the best budget-friendly option, this pack trades volume for accessibility—perfect for those who want to sample the Original Blend without a large investment. Compared to the 100ct version, it costs more per pod but offers flexibility and lower shelf space. It doesn’t introduce new flavors or upgrades, but it delivers the same trusted taste in a compact form. For occasional drinkers, it provides great value and convenience, even if heavy users will outgrow it fast.

Indulge your sweet tooth without the pastry—Tim Hortons’ Caramel Toffee K-Cups bring a festive, dessert-like richness to your Keurig with every brew. This limited-edition flavored coffee layers velvety caramel and sweet toffee notes over a smooth medium roast base, creating a creamy, comforting cup that feels like a treat in a mug. Made with 100% Arabica beans, it avoids the artificial harshness some flavored pods suffer from, delivering a well-integrated, aromatic sweetness that’s bold but not cloying.

In testing, the flavor holds up strongly at 8 oz, with the caramel-toffee blend shining through whether served black or with milk. It brews cleanly in all Keurig models, and the 12-count pack is perfect for seasonal enjoyment or gifting. While it’s not meant for purists seeking bean-forward complexity, it excels as a flavor-forward escape from everyday coffee. That said, the sweetness may overwhelm if consumed in large quantities, and the limited availability means it won’t last year-round.

As the best flavored choice, this variant stands out in a lineup dominated by traditional roasts. Compared to the Original or Dark Roast, it’s less about caffeine strength and more about sensory indulgence—ideal for holidays, afternoon breaks, or anyone craving a sweet coffee lift. It doesn’t replace a classic brew, but it adds joyful variety. It brings more flavor excitement than standard blends, even if it’s not a daily driver.

For those who can’t pick just one, the Tim Horton’s Variety Pack is a taste journey in 30 pods—thoughtfully curated with 18 Original, 6 Dark, and 6 Decaf blends to cover every mood and moment. This mix delivers the full spectrum of Tim Hortons’ coffee personality: balanced medium roast for mornings, bold dark for pick-me-ups, and smooth decaf for evenings. Each pod uses 100% Arabica beans and brews cleanly in Keurig machines, ensuring consistent quality across all three roasts.

In real-world use, the variety eliminates coffee fatigue—no more drinking the same roast day after day. The 30-count is ideal for households with multiple drinkers or anyone who values flexibility and choice. The original blend dominates the pack, which makes sense given its popularity, while the dark and decaf offer strategic contrast. Packaging may vary, but the contents remain unchanged, so there’s no compromise on quality. However, flavored or specialty roasts are absent, limiting the adventure for bold experimenters.

As the best variety mix, this pack outshines single-roast options by offering maximum versatility in one box. Compared to buying individual packs, it’s more convenient and often better priced per pod. It’s not the best for those who only drink one type, but for families or offices, it’s a no-brainer solution. It provides broader flavor access than any single 12 or 24-count pack, making it the ultimate sampler.