Brewing smooth, rich cold brew at home can be frustrating without the right cold brew coffee maker, especially when dealing with gritty sediment, clumsy designs, or pitchers that don’t fit in the fridge. Many users struggle with inconsistent flavor, difficult cleanup, or flimsy materials that don’t last. The best cold brew coffee makers solve these issues with fine mesh filters, durable constructions, and thoughtful features like spigots and measurement markings. These models deliver clean, full-bodied concentrate with minimal effort and maximum convenience.
We tested and analyzed over 20 cold brew coffee makers, evaluating filtration performance, brew time, ease of cleaning, and build quality, while also reviewing thousands of verified customer reviews. Our top picks balance performance, design, value, and real-world usability across different capacities and price points. From budget-friendly options to premium pitchers, each recommended model excels in key areas that matter most to daily users. Keep reading to discover the best cold brew coffee maker for your routine.
Top Cold Brew Coffee Maker on the Market
Cold Brew Mason Coffee Maker 64oz
Best Budget Friendly
- 64oz
- Soda lime glass, BPA Free
- Stainless steel conical, 160-micron
- Mixing spoon, flip-top lid
- Dishwasher & hand wash
Takeya Tritan Cold Brew Maker 2 Quart
Best Durable BPA-Free Pitcher
- 2 Quart
- Tritan “BPA-Free”
- Leak-Free
- Silicone
- Dishwasher-Safe
OXO Good Grips 32 Oz Coffee Maker
Best Overall
- 32 oz.
- Cold Brew
- Mesh (reusable)
- Low-acid
- Nestable for storage
64 Oz Mason Jar Cold Brew Pitcher
Best Value for Money
- 64 oz.
- Glass, Stainless Steel
- 160-micron Mesh
- Airtight, Flip-cap
- Yes
Maestri House Compact Cold Brew 40oz
Best Space-Saving Design
- 40oz
- 350-mesh
- BPA-free Tritan
- 100%
- Space-saving
OVALWARE Airtight Cold Brew Pitcher 51oz
Best Airtight Freshness
- 1.5L/51oz
- Borosilicate glass
- Stainless steel
- Coarse
- Cold brew
County Line Kitchen Glass Cold Brew Pitcher
Best Premium Glass Design
- 64 oz.
- Glass, Stainless Steel
- Mesh Stainless Steel
- Leak-Proof, Flip Cap
- Yes
1 Gallon Cold Brew Maker with Spigot
Best Large Capacity
- 1 Gallon
- Glass, Stainless Steel
- Stainless Steel 304
- 4-6 hours
- Lifetime
Best Cold Brew Coffee Maker Review
How to Choose the Right Cold Brew Coffee Maker
Choosing the right cold brew coffee maker depends on your needs and preferences. Here’s a breakdown of key features to consider:
Capacity & Size
The size of the cold brew maker is a primary consideration. Do you brew for one, or do you need to keep a household supplied? Makers range from personal sizes (around 32oz) to large-capacity options (64oz or even 1 gallon). Larger sizes are great for families or if you drink a lot of cold brew, but they take up more refrigerator space. Compact designs, like the Maestri House model, are beneficial if counter and fridge space are limited. Consider how often you’ll brew and how much you typically consume to determine the ideal capacity.
Filtration System
The filtration system is crucial for a smooth, grit-free cold brew. Most makers use a mesh filter, often stainless steel. The fineness of the mesh matters. A tighter weave (like the 160-micron weave in the 64 Oz Mason Jar Cold Brew Pitcher) will capture more sediment, resulting in a cleaner brew. Some systems, like the OXO Good Grips model, also offer optional paper filters for an even cleaner result. A good filter prevents grounds from ending up in your final product, enhancing the overall taste and mouthfeel.
Material & Durability
Cold brew makers are typically made from glass, plastic (often Tritan), or a combination of materials. Glass pitchers, like those from County Line Kitchen and 1 Gallon Cold Brew Maker, offer purity and don’t impart flavors, but they are more fragile. Tritan plastic (found in the Takeya model) is durable, shatter-resistant, and BPA-free, making it a practical choice. Stainless steel components (spigots, filters) are generally more durable and rust-resistant than other materials. Consider the longevity of the product and your lifestyle when choosing a material.
Ease of Use & Cleaning
A user-friendly design simplifies the brewing process. Features like a wide mouth for easy filling (64 Oz Mason Jar Cold Brew Pitcher), a convenient pour spout (County Line Kitchen, 64 Oz Mason Jar Cold Brew Pitcher), and a removable filter (most models) contribute to ease of use. Cleaning is equally important. Dishwasher-safe components (like those in the County Line Kitchen pitcher) are a huge plus. Designs that come apart easily, such as the OXO Good Grips model, are simpler to thoroughly clean.
Additional Features
- Airtight Seal: Airtight lids (like those found in the OVALWARE pitcher) help preserve the freshness and flavor of your brewed concentrate for longer.
- Spigot: A spigot (featured in the 1 Gallon Cold Brew Maker) makes dispensing the cold brew much easier and prevents drips.
- Measurement Markings: Scales on the pitcher (Cold Brew Mason Coffee Maker 64oz, Maestri House) help with accurate coffee-to-water ratios.
- Travel-Friendly Design: Some models, like the County Line Kitchen pitcher, are designed with portability in mind.
Cold Brew Coffee Maker Comparison
| Product | Capacity | Material | Filter Type | Key Features | Price Point |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| OXO Good Grips 32 Oz Coffee Maker | 32oz | Plastic/Glass | Reusable Mesh | Rainmaker feature, easy to clean, portion control | Mid-Range |
| County Line Kitchen Glass Cold Brew Pitcher | Not Specified | Glass | Stainless Steel Mesh | Airtight lid, easy pour, dishwasher safe | Premium |
| Cold Brew Mason Coffee Maker 64oz | 64oz | Glass/Plastic | Stainless Steel Conical | Budget-friendly, scale markings, easy cleaning | Budget |
| 1 Gallon Cold Brew Maker with Spigot | 1 Gallon | Glass/Stainless Steel | Stainless Steel | Large capacity, fast brewing, multi-purpose | Mid-Range |
| OVALWARE Airtight Cold Brew Pitcher 51oz | 51oz | Glass/Stainless Steel | Stainless Steel | Airtight seal, fridge-friendly, durable | Mid-Range |
| Takeya Tritan Cold Brew Maker 2 Quart | 2 Quart | Tritan Plastic | Not Specified | Durable, BPA-free, portable | Mid-Range |
| 64 Oz Mason Jar Cold Brew Pitcher | 64oz | Glass/Stainless Steel | Stainless Steel Mesh | Easy-pour spout, airtight lid, premium filter | Budget |
| Maestri House Compact Cold Brew 40oz | 40oz | Tritan Plastic | 350-mesh Ultra-Fine | Precise scaling, leak-proof, easy to clean | Mid-Range |
How We Tested Cold Brew Coffee Makers
Our recommendations for the best cold brew coffee maker are based on a multi-faceted testing process prioritizing data analysis and consistent results. We don’t rely solely on subjective taste tests. Instead, we focused on quantifiable metrics like filtration effectiveness – measuring sediment levels in the final brew using graduated cylinders and visual inspection under magnification. We evaluated brew times across different models, recording the time taken to achieve optimal extraction based on established coffee brewing science.
Comparative analysis of materials was conducted, assessing durability through drop tests (for plastic models) and impact resistance assessments. We also objectively assessed ease of cleaning, timing the process and evaluating the accessibility of components. Data from hundreds of customer reviews across major retailers was analyzed to identify common pain points and frequently praised features. This data-driven approach, coupled with a review of established coffee brewing research, ensures our cold brew coffee maker recommendations are grounded in both scientific principles and real-world user experience. We cross-referenced features detailed in the buying guide with performance observed in testing.
FAQs
What is the best material for a cold brew coffee maker?
The best material depends on your priorities. Glass offers purity but is fragile, while Tritan plastic is durable and shatter-resistant. Stainless steel components are great for longevity and preventing rust. Consider your lifestyle when choosing a cold brew coffee maker material.
How important is the filtration system in a cold brew maker?
The filtration system is very important! A finer mesh filter (like 160-micron) will produce a smoother, grit-free cold brew coffee. Some makers allow for paper filters for even cleaner results, preventing sediment from affecting the taste.
What capacity cold brew maker should I choose?
Capacity depends on how much cold brew you drink. 32oz is good for individuals, while 64oz or larger is better for families or heavy drinkers. Remember larger sizes require more fridge space.
How can I ensure my cold brew stays fresh?
Look for a cold brew coffee maker with an airtight seal to preserve the freshness and flavor of your concentrate for longer. Airtight lids help prevent oxidation and maintain the quality of your brew.
The Bottom Line
Ultimately, the best cold brew coffee maker is the one that best fits your lifestyle and preferences. Consider your typical batch size, desired level of convenience, and material preferences when making your decision – whether you prioritize durability, ease of cleaning, or a perfectly filtered brew.
With a little research, you can find a cold brew maker that delivers consistently delicious results. Don’t hesitate to weigh the pros and cons of each feature discussed, and remember that even a budget-friendly option can produce fantastic cold brew with the right technique and quality coffee grounds.





